TV Club: Doctor Who, Black Orchid
Black Orchid (season 19, episodes 17-18. Originally aired March 1-2, 1982)
The most succinct description of what sets Black Orchid apart from the rest of Doctor Who is that its the last of the pure historicalsthat is, a tale that is set in the past, taking advantage of the Doctors ability to travel through time, but otherwise not involving any science-fictional element. In fact, its not only the last of them but a weird anomaly, because this is the kind of story that Doctor Who simply stopped doing at all very early in its run. The pure historical is almost entirely an artifact of William Hartnells First Doctor era, when the show not only hewed closer to its original mission to educate as well as entertain, but had a much broader conception of what kind of stories Doctor Who should be trying to tell.
Ive noted before that one of the strengths of Doctor Who is that its format allows it to drop into not just any time or place, but any genre, any kind of story. The Doctor can appear in the middle of a pastiche on Victorian pulp fiction or Frankenstein movies or Asimovs robot tales, swashbuckle with pirates or match wits with Emperor Nero, teach cavemen the secret of fire or carry the Olympic torch. After the pure historical died out, though, whenever the series played around with other genres, it followed a basic rule: Whatever kind of story the Doctor drops into, its always warped into a Doctor Who version of that story. The Unicorn And The Wasp, for instance, tweaks the standard format of an Agatha Christie mystery by sandwiching it between Doctor Whos science-fiction elementsthe Doctor replaces the traditional detective figure, and a giant alien wasp replaces the traditional Christie killer. Talons Of Weng-Chiang does the same thing with the Sherlock Holmes/Fu Manchu style of late-1800s adventure fiction. But the sci-fi element is always therewithout it, you dont really have a Doctor Who story at all. In the Hartnell era, the pure historicals were the exception to that rule, but that loophole was closed quickly and firmly after Patrick Troughton took over the lead role in season four: His second serial, 1966s The Highlanders, was the last time history would trump science fiction in a Doctor Who story.
Except once.
Originally published July 22, 2012 on avclub.com. Read the complete article.
No Comments
No comments yet.
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.