TV Club: Doctor Who, The Romans
The Romans (season 2, episodes 12-15. Originally aired Jan. 16-Feb. 6, 1965)
Doctor Who was never more willing to experiment with different kinds of stories than during its first couple of seasons, which jumped from the post-apocalyptic monsters of The Daleks to the 13th-century historical epic Marco Polo to the futuristic sci-fi of The Sensorites and back to history again, but with a more farcical touch, in The Romans. Partly this was because it was a good idea to try a varied approach, since nobody was sure yet what fit the show best, but it was also a conscious choice by producer Verity Lambert and the shows first two script editors, David Whitaker and Dennis Spooner. The Romans is a historical story like Marco Polo and The Aztecs, but differs in one crucial respect: Its less interested in the history for its own sake than using it as a backdrop for thrills and comedy.
Its pretty clear that by this point in the series, four stories into the second season, the original idea that Doctor Who should provide both entertainment and lessons in history and science was going by the wayside, if not almost entirely gone. Spooner, who not only wrote this story but made his unofficial debut as script editor here, is not particularly careful with his facts about ancient Roman life, changing Neros age (he was in his mid-20s, not middle-aged) and embracing the legend that he was personally responsible for the Great Fire of Rome, in both cases because it lets him tell the story he wanted to tell instead of, yknow, what actually happened. Not that I have any big problem with that; Doctor Who isnt exactly a documentary, and its not something the series was ever very committed to even at the start.
Originally published Sept. 30, 2012 on avclub.com. Read the complete article.